SU has been around for 25 years and has attracted many devoted users. If you are one of them, please consider the following:
- Using Seismic Unix is not an excuse for non-reproducible computational experiments. To facilitate reproducibility, you can use Python and SCons with the rsf.suproj module supplied by Madagascar. The book/rsf/su directory contains many examples of seismic data processing flows using SU and their loose translation to Madagascar analogs. Here is an example SConstruct script from rsf/su/sulab1
from rsf.suproj import * Flow('plane',None,'suplane') Result('plane','suxwigb label1="Time (s)" label2=Trace') Flow('specfx','plane','suspecfx') Result('specfx','suxwigb label1="Frequency (Hz)" label2=Trace') End()
Its loose Madagascar translation is in rsf/su/rsflab1
from rsf.proj import * Flow('plane',None, ''' spike n1=64 n2=32 d2=1 o2=1 label2=Trace unit2= nsp=3 k1=8,20,32 k2=4 l2=28 p2=2,1,0 ''') Flow('specfx','plane','spectra | scale axis=2') for plot in ('plane','specfx'): Plot(plot, ''' wiggle clip=1 transp=y yreverse=y poly=y wanttitle=n wheretitle=b wherexlabel=t ''') Result('specfx','plane specfx','SideBySideAniso') End()
If you want only rsf.suproj but not the rest of Madagascar, download madagascar-framework package from SourceForge.
It is also possible to convert between SU and RSF file formats with sfsuread and sfsuwrite and to combine SU and Madagascar programs in common processing flows.
If you decide to switch to Madagascar but are missing certain functionality from Seismic Unix, it is possible and legal to borrow code from SU and to add it to Madagascar. The opposite is not true, because the Madagascar license (GPL) is more restrictive than the SU license (BSD-like). The su directory contains some of the codes Madagascar has borrowed from SU by requests of the users. Naturally, we try to limit such borrowing to avoid unnecessary forks.
In a recent message to the Seismic Unix mailing list, John Stockwell described a proposal for S3, the third generation SU. The main requirements for S3 are:
- a new project managed on SourceForge
- GPL license
- flexible trace headers
- integration with scientific libraries
- integration with the current SU as well as other GPL- or BSD-licensed packages
One cannot help thinking that the project that John describes is Madagascar!